Dresses from Shabby Apple

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

An honest post about sleep training......

Well the dreaded topic of sleep training, A.K.A. crying it out, is something I have been meaning to talk about for quite awhile. There is so much negative talk about it the "mom" world and I thought that I would share my views, experience, etc.... Just remember you do not have to agree with me and I am just telling you MY opinion!!

I have had two colicky children, E was by far the hardest and there were few times during the day when she wasn't crying or screaming. She grew out of her colic at about 4 ish months but since I held her all the time she was a little spoiled by me and others. So at 6 months when she was still getting up fifteen times a night, I was was working full time and my husband was out of town all the time, I knew I needed to do something. I also did not want to do it to late because I've heard the older they are the harder it is to break bad habits.. Since she was a good weight and eating solids I thought there is no reason for her to be getting up that often.

First I set myself a goal, she would go to bed at 7:30 and I would not feed her until 2. So if she woke up before that she would be crying her self back to sleep. Well I must have very stubborn children because Emerson was so hard to sleep train. It took us over a month to finally get it to stick and work.

My schedule: To start this I need to say that both of my kids go down really easy but they just don't ever stay asleep..

So the first time I hear them cry I let them cry for ten minutes, I then go in for two minutes and pat or rub their back/tummy but I do not pick up or talk to them, then the next time I hear them cry I let them cry for fifteen minutes and add five minutes each time. I only ever go in there for two minutes when I do go in there.

I'm going to be honest it sucks, it sucks big time!! The first couple nights are the hardest, your tired and the night is dragging on.... but I can tell you when I stuck with it it worked and E is now a much better sleeper. She still has night where she wakes up but I rarely go in there and it rarely happens. Lately she has been waking up I think because of some new molars coming in.

Now I decided to try sleep training earlier with A and I started at 3 months..... she is so much harder to train then E ever was!! Every night is different, she can have a great week and then a bad week..... I am still doing it with her but I feed her twice sometimes three times a night because she is so young and tiny. My doctor said she could sleep through the night but I just want to make sure she is eating enough. But some nights she is up every hour to an hour and a half and to me that is not acceptable. So my rule is she can go at least 4-5 hours at a time before I will feed her. So she goes to bed at 7 and if she wakes up at 11 ish I will nurse and put her back to sleep, then she is up again at 3ish and then for good 6:30ish... I can't figure out how to get her to sleep later than that :( Now this is a good night but this is what I strive for.


This is not easy, it sucks and I have a few days where I will break down and just go hold or nurse her. This of course means I have to start all over again but by 6 months she will only be aloud to wake up once a night..... This is not for every mom but I 100% believe it is great for my children. Sleep is so important and the habits I am teaching them now they will carry with them for the rest of their life. They don't remember this, it's not hurting them and when I go in there and they see me and stop crying I know they are just playing me. It doesn't mean that I think it is easy and I love doing it. But it is a lot harder on me then them and even though I do this it does not mean it does not break my heart. But I do know it is better for them and for us as a family to get them on a good sleeping pattern.....

God Bless

7 comments:

Ashley said...

I think you are doing such a great job! You are right...I believe that sleep training them now is better for them in the long run. I hope it gets easier soon! You deserve some good rest! ; )

Laura said...

Sleep training is such a touchy subject for some people. I totally respect your opinion and everyone has to do what works for their family, but this is just not something that could work for mine. Don’t get me wrong, I did let the munchkin cry a little once she was past the 6 months point, but I based it on her level of angst. If she was crying hard, I always went in there, no matter how much time had passed and rubbed her back until she calmed down. If she was crying uncontrollably, I would pick her up and soothe her and lay her back down as soon as she calmed down. Sometimes this meant, picking her up over and over and spending alot of time going in and out of her room, and it was ridiculously exhausting, but after a few weeks, it worked and now she sleeps so good through the night, pretty much every night. Now, I will say, “Time for bed”, and she will literally run to her room to start her bedtime routine.

My theory, was that I wanted her to know I was there for her, no matter what, but she still had to go to sleep. I didn’t want her to fear sleep, or any part of it. I wanted her to know bed as a comforting place and know there was no reason to fear it. I had no time schedules with going in her room or any real plan of action, I just based it on what felt right to me and I didn’t feel comfortable leaving her in there crying and feeling abandoned. You mentioned forming habits that will last them the rest of their lives, and I totally agree, but not with what habits will be formed. When I talk about the habits being formed for their rest of their lives, I was worried, after reading so many books and theories from psychologists, that letting them cry themselves to sleep could give some children “issues” that they could carry with them into adulthood. I decided that I would rather have the possibility of some sleeping issues while they were kids, rather then the attachment/detachment issues that could help mold their adult personality. It seems, by taking up this approach, she actually now, at 21 months, sleeps better because of it.

Each child is so individual though, and ofcourse you have to base everything on what feels right for your child and your family. I also worked full time, while my husband went to work full time and went to school in the evenings, which left me in a situation similar to yours. I would also have to respectfully disagree with any type of sleep training before the age of six months. I believe they are way too young to manipulate or have any real concept of what is really going on, but they know when they want their mom and I am sure that is all consuming for them at that point in their lives. I realize my ideas may not work for a child more stubborn (although the munchkin was very stubborn herself, sometimes I would spend hours going in and out of her room), but I wanted to offer up my insight into another way of doing it, just to give others a different idea that might be reading this. I don’t think my method is “right” over yours, this is just what feels right to me.

Allie said...

I had to come out of the wood work and comment - thank you so much for this post! My daughter is 4 months and (THANK GOD!) sleeps all night. We know this will change one day (or maybe not?) but this is good advice! Thanks for sharing!

West Family said...

I am right there with you on the sleep training! I am not as structured as you are but I still do a form of CIO. All my friends call me the sleep nazi;) Liam is in bed at 5:30/5:45 and Emma used to go to bed by 5:00! It was nuts but she started with a nap that turned into bedtime.
One of my best friends co-sleeps with her kids. Although it is not best for me and my family it is for her and hers. I am not sure why people judge how your kid sleeps or how they eat. As long as they are healthy and happy that is all that is important!!

Anonymous said...

My kids did not sleep well, although didn't wake as often as often as it sounds like yours do. It hink it's Ferber, but might be Weisbluth, who describes a method of gradually decreasing the amount of time the baby nurses (or feeds) when she wakes at night - Like, if it's 10 min, the next night only 8, next night 6, etc. The idea being (as I vaugely recall) that the full stomach and digestion is what's waking the baby, not actual hunger.

I'm not really one to offer any suggestions, though, because I couldn't stand to hear them cry and especially with my second, I didn't want her crying to wake my son. But being soothe themselves to sleep in the first place is a great sign that they can fall asleep on their own.

Hang in there, one morning you'll wake up and have slept all night. :)

Perfectly Imperfect said...

I firmly believe that each child is completely different and only YOU know what works for your kiddo. We did CIO with BG. I do not regret it at all. We knew she could sleep and she slept great, but she had a hard time going to sleep for a while. It was HARD and she didn't want to give up, but it took three night. That's it. It's so easy to get these little ones used to something. If BG has a few bad nights where we cuddle her or what not (she's sick or something) she comes to expect that. Then we have to do it all over again. But it's a process.. and it works for us.

Do what you need to do girl.

Rachel said...

My two and a half year old didn't start sleeping through the night until about 3 weeks ago... AFTER my second baby was born - so weird! We tried a few different things to try to get her sleep through the night as an itty bitty, but nothing worked.
Good luck, though! Everyone is always happier with more sleep!